Back to Resources
Design & Planning

Garage Conversion vs. Detached ADU: Which is Right for You?

Compare the pros, cons, and costs of garage conversions versus building a detached ADU to find the best option for your property.

ADU Build Pros Team
7 min read
Side by side comparison of garage conversion ADU and detached backyard ADU

When considering building an ADU on your property, you may be faced with the decision between a garage conversion and a detached ADU. Each option has its own advantages and disadvantages, as well as different costs and requirements. This guide helps you compare the pros, cons, and costs of both options to determine which is best for your property.

Key Takeaways:

  • Garage conversions are typically less expensive and faster to build
  • Detached ADUs offer more space and design flexibility
  • Consider your property's layout and zoning laws when making a decision
  • Evaluate long-term needs and potential rental income

Pros of Garage Conversions

Summary: Garage conversions are often the most cost-effective and time-efficient way to add an ADU to your property.

Pros include:

  • Lower material costs
  • Faster construction time
  • No additional setbacks required
  • Potential for higher rental income due to better location

Cons of Garage Conversions

Summary: While garage conversions are cost-effective, they may not be suitable for all properties.

Cons include:

  • Limited space
  • Less design flexibility
  • May require additional parking if not converting existing structure
  • Potential for noise and privacy concerns

Pros of Detached ADUs

Summary: Detached ADUs offer more space and design flexibility, making them a great option for those seeking a larger unit.

Pros include:

  • More space for bedrooms, bathrooms, and living areas
  • Greater design flexibility
  • No additional parking required if within half a mile of public transit
  • Potential for higher rental income due to larger size

Cons of Detached ADUs

Summary: Detached ADUs can be more expensive and time-consuming to build compared to garage conversions.

Cons include:

  • Higher material costs
  • Longer construction time
  • Additional setbacks required
  • Potential for higher utility costs

Cost Comparison

Summary: The cost of building an ADU depends on the type and size of the unit.

Cost comparison:

  • Garage conversions typically cost $30,000 to $80,000
  • Detached ADUs typically cost $80,000 to $200,000 or more

Best Use Cases

Summary: The best ADU type depends on your property's layout, zoning laws, and long-term needs.

Best use cases:

  • Garage conversions for properties with limited space
  • Detached ADUs for properties with ample backyard space
  • Consider zoning laws and setbacks when making a decision
  • Evaluate long-term needs and potential rental income

Let's Build Your Dream ADU

Our team of experts is ready to guide you through every step of your ADU journey.